|
``Sugar Blues'' by William Dufty
The book ``Sugar
Blues'', by William Dufty, is a health book surviving from the 1970s
which surprisingly shows few signs of being dated.
The premise under which the book is written is that sugar is bad--very
bad bad. To kick off the book, the author gives his account of how sugar
affected, or rather controlled, his life until he decided he wanted out.
From there he jumps to a history of sugar in Western civilization, and
from there does topic juggling between more history, medical anecdotes,
relating personal accounts of acquaintances, all while never forgetting to
sound sour notes about refined sugar.
What exactly is so bad about sugar? First of all, the author
suggests that sugar is very much a drug such as heroin in its
effects on the body and the way in which it is refined. (See also: Is
sugar bad for you?) Sugar canes or beets, (as well as rice and
wheat) are stripped from all of their natural vitamins and minerals,
leaving only the non-nutrient portion of the plant left. This refinement
strips the food of its usefulness to man, and in fact, can leave the
food, such as sugar, in the state of being an anti-nutrient.
The book throughout mentions many problems over a broad spectrum of
health problems that sugar consumption can cause: addiction, head-aches,
depression, hyperactivity, tooth decay, diabetes, obesity, worsened
PMS, allergies, lung cancer, scurvy, Alzheimer Disease, weakened
immune system, as well as many many other things. (See also: 108
ways sugar can ruin your health) Not stopping at that, he also
finds that sugar has caused wars, slavery, circumcision, and the buying
out of scientists and doctors to not disturb the industry tied up in
sugar production. Some of the conclusions that he draws make perfect
sense. Others are a bit more of a stretch, although i certainly can not
rule them out.
One example where i wondered if the author was not taking things too
far was that of tobacco and smoking. He suggested that problems
caused by smoking are from the sugar, and not the tar and nicotine as
we are usually lead to believe. While i have not been able to verify
portions of this, the sugar being a function of the curing process
indeed checks out. Furthermore, some stop-smoking sites suggest cutting
back on refined foods while trying to quit smoking, which seems to link
part of the addictive behavior with the sugar. (See: Curing
Tobacco, and Addiction
relapses: nicotine, caffeine, and sugar)
An interesting twist was the portion of the book which discussed how
psychiatrists are unneeded and are trying to talk away problems while
ignoring that they are diet related. For some time i've been of the
opinion that there is little or no need for psychiatrists, but my
reasoning was more along the lines of how that field of human health
was trying to solve problems which could be very spiritually related.
Forgiveness would be a good example; sin can create a huge amount of
mental and emotional baggage which could trigger any number of symptoms.
At the suggestion of William Dufty, i now have all the more reason
to believe that my reasoning against modern psychology practice is
appropriate.
The biggest question that this book raises for me, is to what extent is
the medical world useful and to what extent is natural healing of sorts
preferred. Raised in Western mindset, we are encouraged to trust science,
doctors, the government, and church suggestions on health matters.
Sugar Blues rightfully knocks these assumptions by coming down
very hard on doctors, psychiatrists, the AMA, and the Catholic church.
Meanwhile Dufty very much endorses natural healers and eastern thought
(IE yin and yang)--both of which have very questionable components. The
former, as described by the author, comes very close to the realm of
medicine men, or witch doctors. The later has similar pitfalls. Obviously
there is some truth in both of these, but to what extent, and how
should a Christian relate to these?
Overall this is an excellent book for stimulating thought, as it raises
red flags about numerous facets of Western life. It is also written in
a very entertaining manner, which most any person could find appealing,
although for some, the lack of rigorous scientific presentation may be a
slight turn off.
Some collected excerpts from the book may be found in a Nexus Magazine article entitled
Sugar Blues.
[2003.02.17 10:56] |
[books/health] |
#
|